Marie L. McLaughlin's Myths and Legends of the Sioux (1916) provides a fascinating window into the cultural, spiritual, and moral frameworks of the Sioux nation. This collection, which preserves oral traditions passed down through generations, serves as a bridge between the individual and collective identities of the Sioux people, reflecting their deep connection to nature, spirituality, and social values. Drawing on Carl Jung's concept of archetypes, Jacques Lacan's psychoanalytic theory, and Roland Barthes's semiotic approach, this essay examines McLaughlin's work as a repository of cultural texts that transcend time. It also incorporates my very personal reflections and insights inspired by the legends, characters, and morals presented in these myths, offering a multidimensional exploration of their enduring significance.

Introduction to the Worldview of the Sioux People

The Sioux worldview, as depicted in McLaughlin’s collection, reflects a profound connection between humanity, nature, and the spiritual realm. Drawing on Baird’s (n.d.) insights into Parallelism in Sioux and Sami Spiritual Traditions, the Sioux Nation’s perspective emphasizes that all things are sacred, interconnected, and imbued with spirit. This sacred interconnectedness permeates McLaughlin’s storytelling, where each narrative illustrates the spiritual bond between humans and their environment. From a Jungian perspective, this worldview aligns with the concept of the collective unconscious, where archetypes such as the Great Spirit (Wakan Tanka) and trickster figures such as Iktomi serve as universal symbols that transcend cultural boundaries. Byron-Cox and Williams (2023) describe the collective unconscious as “wisdom from our ancestors passed down through genetic materials,” independent of individual experience. This aligns seamlessly with Sioux spirituality, which upholds the integration of ancestral wisdom into daily life. Additionally, Jung’s notion of the “Self,” which initiates life and guides individuation, resonates with the Sioux emphasis on harmony between the physical and metaphysical realms. As McGehee (2014) notes, “the Self initiates life and it is life’s goal,” and this journey toward becoming one’s true, autonomous self is vividly depicted in the transformations of McLaughlin’s Sioux mythological characters.

If one had the chance to ask Jacques Lacan for his insights into these legends, he would probably tell us that the myths in Myths and Legends of the Sioux belong to the "Symbolic Order," a realm where language, cultural narratives, and communal values shape individual subjectivity. As May-Hobbs (2023) explains, "The Symbolic is the register, first and foremost, of language, and for Lacan, it is language that Freud has failed to reckon with." Furthermore, May-Hobbs elaborates that "the Symbolic Order encompasses not just language but also all the other social and representational structures upon which conscious daily life rests." Within this framework, the Sioux’s oral traditions serve as a linguistic and cultural system that structures their worldview, embedding individuals into a shared cultural matrix.

Roland Barthes extends this perspective by positioning these myths as "mythologies," or cultural codes through which the Sioux interpret their environment and existence. These narratives assign layered meanings to natural phenomena and spiritual forces, functioning as tools for constructing and transmitting collective identity. As Whitworth (2023) observes, "according to Roland Barthes, myths occur when society’s dominant institutions imbue an image, object, or phrase with meaning. By forming these associations, the dominant social institutions create and reinforce cultural beliefs and values that are unconsciously adopted by the masses." In the Sioux context, such mythologies not only articulate their cultural values but also perpetuate their spiritual and social worldview.

Morality and Social Lessons

Sioux myths often convey moral lessons, emphasizing virtues such as generosity, honesty, and respect. As Olmos-Gómez, Portillo-Sánchez, Mohamed-Mohand, and Estrada-Vidal (2024) observe, quoting Hamilton and Adamson’s (2013) work, these virtues align with "prosocial behaviors" that are "carried out by an individual with a clear intention to help and benefit another person or group. This includes acts of aiding, collaborating, caring, donating, and sharing, always with the recipient’s well-being in mind." Such prosocial behaviors are vividly illustrated in Sioux mythology, where characters often prioritize the care and well-being of their clan members.

Jung’s archetype of the “Wise Old Man” is a recurring motif in these stories, manifesting in elders who provide guidance and underscore the importance of collective wisdom over individual desire. As described in Envision Your Evolution (2019), the Wise Old Man is "a profound philosopher distinguished for wisdom and sound judgment." This archetype reflects the Sioux’s cultural emphasis on communal well-being, where the wisdom of elders plays a crucial role in maintaining harmony and fostering shared values within the community.

From Lacan’s perspective, the moral lessons in Sioux myths embody the “Law of the Father,” representing societal norms and prohibitions internalized by individuals. As Hook (2016) explains, “What Lacan calls the Name-of-the-Father refers to the influence of cultural and social law within the family, something which has traditionally—especially within patriarchal societies—been associated with the actual figure of the father.” Sioux myths instill adherence to these norms by illustrating the consequences of disobedience, thus reinforcing the “Law of the Father” as a cornerstone of communal life.

Barthes’s semiotic theory complements this view by highlighting how moral tales function as signs, encoding Sioux values into enduring narratives. As observed by Media Studies (n.d.), “Some signs are used to represent a more complex concept, such as the shared values and ideologies of a particular culture or group.” In Sioux culture, these stories not only transmit ethical principles but also solidify communal identity, embedding shared values deeply within the social fabric.

Trickery as a Tool for Teaching

The trickster Iktomi embodies the Jungian archetype of the “Shadow,” representing repressed instincts and the chaotic aspects of human nature. According to Lonngi (n.d.), the Shadow is “the part of our unconscious mind that Jung believed to hold all the things about ourselves that we repress, whether because they are evil, socially unacceptable, harmful to others, or detrimental to our own health.” Through Iktomi’s tales, the Sioux articulate a nuanced view of morality, where deception serves both as a cautionary tale and a tool for learning. Iktomi’s misadventures often uncover deeper truths about the human condition, resonating with Jung’s assertion that confronting the Shadow is vital for personal growth—whether it involves addressing socially unacceptable behavior or fostering harmony within the tribe.

Lacan would interpret Iktomi as a figure who disrupts the Symbolic Order, exposing gaps and inconsistencies in societal structures. As Philo-Notes (2023) explains, Lacan “argued that individuals are socialized into the symbolic order through their interactions with others, and that the individual’s sense of identity is shaped by the cultural values and norms that are transmitted to them through language.” Iktomi’s tricks subvert expectations, compelling both characters and listeners to reassess their assumptions about the social order they have been conditioned to accept. For Barthes, Iktomi’s tales function as cultural texts layered with meaning, employing humor and irony to critique social norms while ultimately reaffirming communal values. These stories exemplify what Barthes describes as “cultural texts,” referring to everyday objects, images, and social practices that encode meanings and ideologies. As Media Studies (n.d.) observes, such texts can be decoded through the study of signs; consequently, semiotics could reveal what the Sioux consider essential for their nation’s identity and continuity.

The Wisdom of Elders and Animals

Elders and animals in Sioux myths embody the archetypes of the Sage and the Guide, underscoring the values of humility and interdependence. Analyzing the characters in Sioux legends reveals that they are “driven by a quest for truth, fearing being misled”—often by Iktomi—or remaining “ignorant” (Copley, 2024). Jung’s concepts of the Anima and Animus—representing feminine and masculine energies within individuals—are reflected in the harmonious balance these figures promote between humans and nature. As Copley (2024) notes, this duality “represents the unconscious opposite gender qualities within individuals,” often manifesting “in dreams, fantasies, and interpersonal relationships,” something we readers can see happening in the lives of the characters.

For Lacan, the respect for elders and animals signifies a connection to the Real—the pre-symbolic domain of raw, unmediated experience. The Real, as defined by Lacan, “can only be understood in connection with the categories of the symbolic and the imaginary. Defined as what escapes the symbolic, the real can be neither spoken nor written” (Encyclopedia.com, n.d.). Sioux myths preserve this connection, reminding listeners or readers of the primal wisdom inherent in nature. This Lacanian Real represents an inaccessible dimension of existence, resisting representation through language and manifesting in legends as an interplay between the imaginary and the symbolic, rooted in the language used to tell the stories. Barthes’s concept of myth as a system of signs complements this perspective, highlighting how these tales encode cultural reverence for elders and animals, portraying them as embodiments of Sioux identity and spirituality. In Barthes’s framework, a “sign” consists of a “signifier” (Nicolas, 2019) (the physical form, such as a spider or Iktomi) and a “signified” (Nicolas, 2019) (the meaning associated with that form, such as trickery or deceit). These ideas of “signifier” and “signified” are present throughout all these Sioux tales.

Obedience and the Consequences of Defiance

Many Sioux myths emphasize obedience to elders and spiritual laws, reflecting Jung’s archetype of the Ruler, which embodies authority and structure. This archetype “inspires us to take responsibility for our own lives, in our fields of endeavor, and in society at large” (Jonas, n.d.). In these myths, disobedience disrupts the archetypal order, leading to chaos that must be resolved to restore harmony. As Jonas (n.d.) explains, “the Ruler's quest is to create order and structure and hence an effective society in which the subjects of the Ruler can live productive and relatively happy lives.”

Lacan’s notion of the “Mirror Stage” offers another layer of interpretation. Characters who defy authority often experience a fractured sense of identity, reflecting the psychological tension between personal desires and societal expectations. During this stage, “Lacan emphasizes that the mirror stage is about identification. It is, as Lionel Bailly writes, ‘the first time the child thinks of itself as ‘I’ in relationship with an image that it starts to understand as representing itself’” (Lacan, 2012, as quoted by Allen, 2023). Barthes would interpret these tales as narratives that “naturalize” cultural norms, framing obedience as essential for maintaining social cohesion. As McLaverty-Robinson (2011) observes, “Naturalisation leads to the silencing of difference.” In Sioux myths, this is evident as elders project onto their people a set of “organized statutes” rooted in ancestral traditions and cultural practices.

The Role of Spirituality and the Supernatural

Spirituality is deeply embedded in Sioux myths, with supernatural forces frequently intervening to teach or protect. Jung’s concept of the “Numinous”—a profound sense of awe and wonder linked to the divine—provides a lens through which to understand the Sioux’s reverence for the Great Spirit and natural forces. As Dr. Santana (2017) explains, “The feelings of awe, dread, and amazement that accompany a numinous experience are important not simply because they help us to identify the experience as sacred.” This is evident in Sioux mythology, where numinous experiences such as prophetic dreams or remarkable synchronicities often signal transitions or the unearthing of significant new phases. Dr. Santana (2017) further notes, “Within these experiences there is a union of matter and spirit, a connection between something real and something more than real.” This intertwining of the spiritual and the material reflects the Sioux’s theogony, shaping how they interact with the supernatural world, animals, and their environment.

For Lacan, the supernatural elements in Sioux myths symbolize the “Other,” representing the unknown and transcendent aspects of existence that resist comprehension. As Benson (2018) explains, “This reification [the Other] acknowledges our capacity for detaching the concept of the Other from any specific person and even from any physical entities such as rivers and trees and stones. Lacan further thinks that it is by this abstraction of the concept of Otherness that we generate a concept of God.” This conception of the Other, or God, is evident in the Sioux legends compiled by McLaughlin in Myths and Legends of the Sioux, where the Sioux people embrace spirituality and eternal beings as forces shaping reality and the ineffable. Barthes’s insights provide a complementary perspective, illustrating how these myths construct a semiotic framework that the Sioux use to interpret their spiritual experiences, endowing natural and supernatural phenomena with layered meanings. As Morous-Baird (2014) notes, “The special trick of myth is to present an ethos, ideology, or set of values as if it were a natural condition of the world,” reflecting the Sioux’s collective traditions and worldview. Furthermore, “A myth doesn’t describe the natural state of the world, but expresses the intentions of its teller,” Morous-Baird continues, “be that a storyteller, priest, artist, journalist, filmmaker, designer or politician.” In the Sioux context, these intentions are intricately tied to their understanding of self and the spiritual universe surrounding them.

Nature as a Mirror for Human Experience

Nature in Sioux mythology functions as a symbolic reflection of human actions and emotions. As noted by The Jungian Confrerie (n.d.), “The mother archetype is a universal pattern or image that is present in the collective unconscious of all humans, according to Carl Jung.” This archetype “represents the concept of the nurturing and caring mother, as well as the power and wisdom of the divine feminine” (The Jungian Confrerie, n.d.). The Sioux nation reflects this archetypal image in their myths, where nature is portrayed as a nurturing yet formidable force that demands respect. Jung’s archetype of the Earth Mother is evident in these depictions, as seen in the legends presented in McLaughlin’s Myths and Legends of the Sioux, highlighting the Sioux’s profound connection to their natural environment and its dual role as both a caregiver and a force to be reckoned with.

Lacan’s Real—the unmediated, raw aspect of existence—resonates in these tales, where nature’s reactions to human behavior underscore the interconnectedness of all life. According to the Theories of Media: Keywords Glossary by the University of Chicago (n.d.), “Very unlike our conventional conception of objective/collective experience, in Lacanian theory the real becomes that which resists representation, what is pre-mirror, pre-imaginary, pre-symbolic – what cannot be symbolized – what loses its ‘reality’ once it is symbolized (made conscious) through language” (The University of Chicago: Theories of Media, n.d.). This perspective aligns with the Sioux understanding of the natural world, which reflects a profound relationship beyond mere linguistic or symbolic representation.

Barthes’s semiotic approach further elucidates how these myths transform natural elements into cultural symbols, reinforcing the Sioux worldview and values. As noted by Media Theory (2023), “Barthes’ seminal work, Mythologies, published in 1957, then offered a fresh lens through which to examine everyday cultural phenomena. In this collection of essays, he dissected seemingly mundane aspects of popular culture, revealing their hidden layers of meaning.” Through this lens, the symbolism of nature in Sioux legends can be analyzed as a cultural text, where natural phenomena and their interconnectedness with human lives are imbued with layered, culturally specific meanings.

Conclusion: McLaughlin’s Legacy and Contemporary Theoretical Insights

Marie L. McLaughlin’s Myths and Legends of the Sioux is more than a collection of stories; it is a bridge between the rich heritage of the Sioux people and the universal themes that resonate across cultures. These myths serve as a repository of cultural wisdom, preserving the Sioux worldview while addressing fundamental questions about identity, morality, and spirituality. By exploring the archetypes within these tales, as Jung suggests, readers are guided through universal patterns such as the nurturing Earth Mother, the wise Elder, and the trickster Iktomi, all of which reveal the delicate balance between humanity and nature. The myths emphasize interdependence and respect for the natural world, values that remain vital in today’s global challenges.

From Lacan’s perspective, these myths expose the tensions between personal desires and societal expectations, reflecting the fractured identities that arise from such conflicts. Characters like Iktomi act as disruptions to the Symbolic Order, highlighting the gaps and inconsistencies in societal structures. Similarly, the portrayal of the “Other” in the Sioux spiritual framework reflects Lacan’s notion of the Real—a raw, unmediated dimension of existence that eludes representation. This dimension, deeply embedded in the Sioux connection to nature and spirituality, invites readers to reflect on what lies beyond language and conscious thought, offering profound insights into the human condition.

Barthes’s semiotic approach provides yet another layer of understanding, analyzing how these myths transform natural elements into powerful cultural symbols. Nature in Sioux legends does not merely function as a backdrop but becomes a signifier imbued with meaning, communicating values of interconnectedness, respect, and reverence for the divine. These stories, through their layered symbolism, serve as “cultural texts” that encode the Sioux’s collective identity and ethos. McLaughlin’s work thus transcends its historical context, offering timeless lessons and fostering a dialogue between past and present. In a world increasingly disconnected from its roots, these myths remind us of the power of storytelling to educate, inspire, and sustain cultural heritage.

References

Allen, P. (2023, October 26). What is Lacan’s Mirror Stage? Retrieved January 8, 2025, from Perlego: https://www.perlego.com/knowledge/study-guides/what-is-lacans-mirror-stage/

Baird, B. (n.d.). Parallelism in Sioux and Sami Spiritual Traditions. Retrieved December 21, 2024, from https://www.laits.utexas.edu/: https://www.laits.utexas.edu/sami/diehtu/siida/religion/paralellism.htm#:~:text=For%20the%20Sioux%20and%20the,their%20prey%20and%20their%20enemies.

Benson, P. (2018). The Concept of the Other from Kant to Lacan. Retrieved January 10, 2025, from Philosophy Now: https://philosophynow.org/issues/127/The_Concept_of_the_Other_from_Kant_to_Lacan#:~:text=In%20Lacan's%20early%20work%2C%20small,itself'%20as%20we%20might%20say.

Byron-Cox, H., & Williams, Y. (2023, November 11). Collective Unconscious by Carl Jung | Definition & Examples. Retrieved October 22, 2024, from Study.Com: https://study.com/academy/lesson/collective-unconscious-definition-examples.html#:~:text=The%20term%20'collective%20unconscious'%20can,involuntary%20responses%20to%20circumstantial%20stimuli.

Copley, L. (2024, April 8). 12 Jungian Archetypes: The Foundation of Personality. Retrieved January 6, 2025, from PositivePsychology.Com: https://positivepsychology.com/jungian-archetypes/#the-12-jungian-archetypes

Encyclopedia.Com. (nd.). Real, the (Lacan). Retrieved January 6, 2025, from Encyclopedia.Com: https://www.encyclopedia.com/psychology/dictionaries-thesauruses-pictures-and-press-releases/real-lacan#:~:text=41)%2C%20then%20how%20must%20analysis,at%20the%20expense%20of%20meaning.

Envision Your Evolution. (2019, June 19). The Wise Old Man: Exploring the Psychology of the Archetype. Retrieved October 18, 2024, from Envision Your Evolution: https://www.envisionyourevolution.com/analytical-psychology/the-wise-old-man-archetype-anatomy/1795/

Hook, D. (2016). What, for Lacan, makes the function of the Father work? Of Abraham and the goat, or, of Elliott and ET. doi:https://doi.org/10.17159/2309-8708/2016/n51a9

Jonas, J. J. (n.d.). The Twelve Archetypes. Retrieved January 8, 2025, from https://www.uiltexas.org/files/: https://www.uiltexas.org/files/capitalconference/Twelve_Character_Archetypes.pdf

Lonngi, G. (n.d.). The Jungian Shadow and Self-Acceptance. Retrieved January 5, 2024, from The Nautilus - Student Newspaper at Texas A&M University at Galveston: https://www.tamug.edu/nautilus/articles/The%20Jungian%20Shadow%20and%20Self-Acceptance.html#:~:text=Enter%20the%20Shadow.,detrimental%20to%20our%20own%20health.

May-Hobbs, M. (2023, September 20). Jacques Lacan: Explaining the Imaginary, the Symbolic, and the Real. Retrieved December 23, 2024, from The Collector: https://www.thecollector.com/jacques-lacan-imaginary-symbolic-real/

McGehee, J. P. (2014). Jungian Self. Retrieved November 13, 2024, from Encyclopedia of Psychology and Religion: https://link.springer.com/referenceworkentry/10.1007/978-1-4614-6086-2_368#citeas

Mclaughlin, M. L. (1916). Myths and Legends of the Sioux. Bismark, North Dakota, USA: Bismark Tribune Co.

McLaverty-Robinson, A. (2011, October 7). Roland Barthes’s Mythologies: Naturalisation, Politics and everyday life An A to Z of Theory. Retrieved January 8, 2025, from CeaseFire: https://ceasefiremagazine.co.uk/in-theory-barthes-3/

Media Studies. (n.d.). Roland Barthes. Retrieved January 5, 2025, from Media Studies: https://media-studies.com/barthes/#:~:text=The%20idiom%20%E2%80%9Ctake%20the%20pressure,we%20now%20take%20for%20granted.

Media Studies. (n.d.). Sign Theory. Retrieved October 25, 2024, from Media Studies: https://media-studies.com/barthes/

Media Theory. (2023, December 24). Roland Barthes | Decoding the Semiotics of Media & Culture. Retrieved January 11, 2025, from Media Theory: https://mediatheory.net/roland-barthes/

Morous-Baird, G. (2014, November 11). Roland Barthes’ definition of myth. Retrieved January 10, 2025, from Celtic Source: https://celticsource.online/roland-barthes-definition-of-myth/

Nicolas, C. (2019, April 27). The world is full of signs — here’s a quick guide on how to read them. Retrieved January 2025, 2025, from Medium: https://nicolas-celnik.medium.com/the-world-is-full-of-signs-heres-a-quick-guide-on-how-to-read-them-91bc0f6082f4#:~:text=It%20relies%20on%20a%20socio,is%20genuinely%20a%20good%20beer'.

Olmos-Gómez, M. d., Portillo-Sánchez, R., Mohamed-Mohand, L., & Estrada-Vidal, L. I. (2024, February 19). Promotion of Values Education (Factors Involved in Prosocial Behaviors and Volunteering). European Journal of Investigation in Health, Pshychology and Education, 14(2), 411-431. doi: 10.3390/ejihpe14020028

Philo-Notes. (2023, April 1). What is Symbolic Oder? Retrieved January 5, 2025, from https://philonotes.com/: https://philonotes.com/2023/04/what-is-symbolic-order#:~:text=Lacan%20argued%20that%20the%20symbolic,make%20sense%20of%20their%20world.

Santana, E. (2017, March 8). Healing Through Numinous Encounters: A Jungian Approach. Retrieved January 10, 2025, from Dr. Ed Santana: https://www.dredsantana.com/articles/2018/3/6/healing-through-numinous-encounters-a-jungian-approach

The Jungian Confrerie. (n.d.). The Mother Archetype. Retrieved January 11, 2025, from The Jungina Confrerie.

The University of Chicago: Theories of Media, K. G. (n.d.). Symbolic, real, imaginary. Retrieved January 11, 2025, from The University of Chicago :: Theories of Media :: Keywords Glossary.

Whitworth, E. (2023, February 7). Mythologies by Barthes: Overview & Primary Themes. Retrieved December 3, 2024, from Shortform: https://www.shortform.com/blog/mythologies-by-barthes/

Introduction

Robert Gagné’s Nine Events of Instruction offer a structured and systematic approach to teaching, guiding learners through different stages of acquiring knowledge and skills. However, when integrated with other influential learning theories, such as Lev Vygotsky’s Sociocultural Theory, Alexander Luria’s Neuropsychological Development of Learning, and Richard Schmidt’s Noticing Hypothesis, Gagné’s model can be further enriched to deepen understanding and enhance communicative language teaching. This essay explores how these three theoretical frameworks complement Gagné’s instructional events, focusing on language acquisition and the cognitive and social processes involved in learning.

1. Gaining Attention: The Role of Social Interaction in Learning

In Gagné’s first event, gaining attention of the students (Northern Illinois University Center for Innovative Teaching and Learning, 2020), it is crucial to engage learners from the outset. Vygotsky’s Sociocultural Theory emphasizes the importance of social interaction as a catalyst for cognitive development. According to the Office of Educational Improvement at the Medical College of Wisconsin (2022), “The sociocultural theory of cognitive development explores the influence the world has on individual development. It asserts that learning is a mostly social process whereby development occurs through interactions with people who possess more knowledge or skill than the learner.” From Vygotsky’s perspective, attention is gained not only through external stimuli but also through joint activity and social scaffolding. Teachers can activate student attention by engaging them in collaborative tasks that foster a sense of shared learning. For example, asking students to solve a problem together or engage in a dialogue captures their attention while creating a social context for learning.

Luria’s neuropsychological perspective adds depth to this process by highlighting the brain’s attentional systems and their responsiveness to novelty and relevance. Jha (2020) explains, “Our attention system is necessary for almost every single thing we do—whether it’s listening to my voice right now, focus on something you’re reading, communicate, learn or problem solve.” To help students acquire new knowledge and skills, teachers can present content in ways that actively engage the prefrontal cortex, which is responsible for executive functions. By relating tasks to learners’ personal experiences, educators can make learning more meaningful. Within Gagné’s model, incorporating real-world examples—such as discussions about current events—effectively stimulates attention by aligning with the learners’ emotional and cognitive states.

2. Informing Learners of the Objective: Establishing the Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD)

Gagné’s second event involves informing learners of the instructional objectives, a step that helps students understand what they are expected to learn and achieve. As educators, we must clearly communicate these objectives to align learning activities with desired outcomes. Vygotsky’s concept of the Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD) is particularly relevant here. According to the Medical College of Wisconsin’s Office of Educational Improvement (2022), the ZPD “is the difference between what a learner can achieve independently and what they can learn with the guidance and support.” By setting objectives that fall within learners’ ZPD, teachers ensure the goals are appropriately challenging—neither too simple nor overly complex. For instance, in a language lesson, the teacher might explain that the objective is to understand a dialogue about travel, ensuring the task matches the learners’ developmental readiness and supports guided progression toward mastery.

Luria’s research on language processing highlights the importance of designing objectives that activate specific neural pathways associated with sequencing, monitoring, and planning skills. According to Spina Bifida Hydrocephalus Scotland (n.d.), “Planning, sequencing and monitoring are the kinds of thinking we need to do to successfully achieve our goal or solve a problem. We need to think about what needs to be done, and the order to do it in.” Educators can apply this insight by structuring classroom activities that encourage learners to plan, execute a sequence of tasks, and monitor their outcomes. By aligning objectives and tasks with learners’ cognitive capacities, teachers can ensure that these activities fall within the Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD) while engaging the brain’s processing systems effectively.

3. Stimulating Recall of Prior Learning: Bridging Past and New Knowledge Through Noticing

Stimulating recall, Gagné’s third event, aligns closely with Schmidt’s Noticing Hypothesis, which asserts that language learners must first notice linguistic features to internalize and learn them. While teachers play a critical role in guiding learners to notice essential information, they must also help students connect new material to prior knowledge. As the Northern Illinois University Center for Innovative Teaching and Learning (2020) explains, educators should “help students make sense of new information by relating it to something they already know or something they have already experienced.” By recalling prior knowledge, learners are better prepared to notice and integrate new concepts.

For example, before introducing new grammatical structures, teachers can encourage students to reflect on related structures they already understand. This approach activates Schmidt’s idea of noticing gaps or discrepancies in their knowledge, paving the way for deeper learning. It is essential to remember that “a student’s education builds on previous concepts like building blocks. If you’re missing foundation blocks at the bottom, you can’t keep building. If a student has learning gaps, they can’t keep building and learning more complex concepts” (Hegwood, 2022). Addressing these gaps is crucial, as they can significantly impede further learning and progress.

Incorporating Luria’s neuropsychological approach, Gagné’s third event, Recall of Prior Knowledge, leverages the brain’s memory systems to support learning. Luria emphasized that linking new information to existing neural connections strengthens knowledge retention. As McAllister (2020) explains, “When you learn something, you have electrical activity going through different circuits. Those electrical impulses change the strength of specific connections, making them either stronger or weaker.” By stimulating recall, educators create a neural bridge between established concepts and new input, facilitating smoother language acquisition and deeper cognitive engagement.

4. Presenting the Content: Mediated Learning and the Noticing of Key Features

In Gagné’s fourth event, the presentation of content is where the bulk of new information is provided to the learner. Based on Northern Illinois University Center for Innovative Teaching and Learning (2020), we teacher need to uUse strategies to present and cue lesson content to provide more effective instruction.” And we also must “organize and group content in meaningful ways, and provide explanations after demonstrations” (Northern Illinois University Center for Innovative Teaching and Learning, 2020). Vygotsky’s concept of mediated learning is especially relevant here, as the teacher or more knowledgeable peer helps learners make sense of the content by providing cognitive scaffolds. For example, the teacher might model a conversation, breaking down language structures and explaining their use. This aligns with Gagné’s presentation of content by ensuring that learners receive the necessary input for understanding.

According to Schmidt’s Noticing Hypothesis, this phase of stimulating recall is an ideal opportunity for teachers to direct learners’ attention to specific linguistic features. For example, in a lesson on the past tense, the teacher might highlight verbs such as "went" or "saw," ensuring students notice the grammatical structure. This approach reinforces explicit learning, which is “characterized by ‘more conscious operation where the individual makes and tests hypotheses in a search for structure’” (Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, 2012). By consciously focusing on new forms during this phase, learners are more likely to retain and effectively use the language in future contexts.

5. Providing Learning Guidance: Scaffolding Within the ZPD

Providing guidance is essential for helping learners internalize new content. At this stage, instructors must “advise students of strategies to aid them in learning content and of resources available. In other words, [teachers] help students learn how to learn” (Northern Illinois University Center for Innovative Teaching and Learning, 2020). Vygotsky’s concept of scaffolding is pivotal to this process, emphasizing the need to “break up the learning into chunks and provide a tool, or structure, with each chunk” (Alber, 2011) so that students can understand and apply newly acquired knowledge in various contexts. Acting as facilitators, teachers offer step-by-step support as learners navigate new language tasks. This guidance diminishes over time as learners gain proficiency, eventually enabling independent work. For example, a teacher might begin by providing sentence starters during a speaking activity, gradually reducing this support as learners build confidence and fluency.

Luria’s insights into higher psychological functions—such as planning, attention, and memory—underscore the importance of effective guidance in structuring learners’ cognitive processes. These higher mental functions are “socially created, voluntarily controlled, semiotically mediated and united in systems with other functions” (Subbotsky, n.d.), enabling purposeful learning. When instructors break tasks into manageable components and guide learners through them, they activate the brain’s problem-solving circuits, enhancing language production and supporting the internalization of new vocabulary and structures.

6. Eliciting Performance: Collaborative and Noticed Performance

In Gagné’s sixth event, eliciting performance, learners are encouraged to demonstrate their understanding and apply newly acquired skills. This stage allows instructors to “have students apply what they have learned to reinforce new skills and knowledge and to confirm correct understanding of course concepts” (Northern Illinois University Center for Innovative Teaching and Learning, 2020). Vygotsky’s emphasis on social collaboration is particularly relevant here, as learners often perform better when engaging with peers. For example, role-playing in pairs or small groups enables students to use language in meaningful, interactive contexts. This aligns with Vygotsky’s belief that learning is most effective in socially rich environments, as he “emphasized the collaborative nature of learning by constructing knowledge through social negotiation” (McLeod, 2024).

Schmidt’s Noticing Hypothesis highlights that eliciting performance is the critical moment when learners must consciously apply what they have noticed. As Schmidt explains, “the extent of attention determines the degree of noticing in the input, and that input has to be noticed before it becomes intake” (Buriro & Kakepoto, 2023). By actively producing the language they have focused on in earlier stages, learners ensure that noticing transitions into practical language use. For example, students might engage in dialogues where they deliberately apply newly noticed grammatical structures or vocabulary, solidifying their understanding and making the language accessible for future communication.

7. Providing Feedback: Cognitive Development and Noticing Errors

Feedback is crucial in any learning process, and Gagné’s seventh event emphasizes providing corrective feedback to learners. At this stage, instructors must “provide timely feedback of students’ performance to assess and facilitate learning and to allow students to identify gaps in understanding before it is too late” (Northern Illinois University Center for Innovative Teaching and Learning, 2020). Vygotsky’s theory underscores the importance of interactive feedback, enabling learners to reflect on their mistakes and learn within the ZPD. As Ćehić (n.d.) reminds us, “human interaction lies at the core of verbal feedback. The interpersonal aspect of speaking and listening promotes a sense of connection between the giver and receiver of feedback. This connection can lead to increased engagement, motivation, and trust, ultimately enhancing the learning experience.” To strengthen these connections, teachers can pose guiding questions that encourage students to self-correct, transforming feedback into a constructive dialogue rather than mere correction.

Schmidt’s Noticing Hypothesis complements this event, emphasizing that learners must first notice errors to correct them. Although “learners will react differently to different types of error correction depending on their individual characteristics” (Bakan et al., 2020), unnoticed mistakes are unlikely to result in lasting improvement. Effective feedback should help students become aware of linguistic inaccuracies, enabling them to adjust their understanding and enhance their performance. For example, after a role-play activity, the teacher might highlight misused past-tense verbs, encouraging students to notice the errors and make the necessary corrections.

8. Assessing Performance: Formative and Summative Assessment Aligned with ZPD

Gagné’s eighth event focuses on assessing learners’ performance through both formative and summative methods. At this stage, instructors must “implement a variety of assessment methods to provide students with multiple opportunities to demonstrate proficiency” (Northern Illinois University Center for Innovative Teaching and Learning, 2020), particularly in language learning. Vygotsky’s concept of the Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD) enriches this approach by emphasizing that assessments should evaluate not only what learners can accomplish independently but also what they can achieve with guidance. Formative assessments, such as peer evaluations or teacher feedback during group activities, provide valuable insights into learners’ progress while identifying areas for future growth and development.

From Luria’s perspective, assessment should account for learners’ cognitive processing abilities, emphasizing how effectively they can sequence and organize language use. “Whenever [learners] see or hear something new, [they] go through a series of cognitive processes, which are the processes that result in learning” (Mccaw & Diamond, 2023). This focus on cognitive processes aligns with Schmidt’s Noticing Hypothesis, which highlights the importance of learners paying attention to linguistic features to acquire them. Consequently, summative assessments should not only measure output but also foster learners’ ability to notice and correct their own errors. Teachers can encourage students to reflect on their learning, evaluate how well they noticed key features, and track their progress over time. As Schmidt (1995) observed, “L2 proficiency might be a significant contributing factor in determining whether or not students noticed error corrections and understood the nature of errors so noticed,” ultimately enhancing the cognitive processes that drive learning.

9. Enhancing Retention and Transfer: Building Cognitive and Social Competence

The final event in Gagné’s model emphasizes enhancing retention and transfer, ensuring learners can effectively apply their knowledge in new contexts. Teachers are expected to “help learners retain more information by providing them opportunities to connect course concepts to potential real-world applications” (Northern Illinois University Center for Innovative Teaching and Learning, 2020). Vygotsky’s theory underscores the role of social interaction in consolidating learning, suggesting that students who engage collaboratively and use language in varied settings are more likely to retain and transfer their knowledge. Educators can foster this through activities like group projects or real-world language tasks, such as presentations or debates.

Schmidt’s Noticing Hypothesis highlights the importance of continued noticing for long-term retention. Learners should be encouraged to observe language use in authentic contexts, such as media or conversations, even beyond the classroom. This practice reinforces understanding and facilitates transfer to new situations. Teachers can emphasize to students the critical need for reinforcement, noting that “the statistics on learning retention can be alarming if [we] take them at face value” (Clearwater, n.d.). Instructors need to be certain that, as Clearwarter (n.d.) suggests that “research on the forgetting curve shows that within 1 hour, learners forget an average of 50% of the information presented; within 24 hours, they forget an average of 70%; and within a week, up to 90% of what they ‘learned’” (Clearwater, n.d.). By addressing this forgetting curve, educators can help ensure that learners retain and build upon what they have noticed in class or independently.

Conclusion

Gagné’s Nine Events of Instruction, when paired with Vygotsky’s Sociocultural Theory, Luria’s Neuropsychological Development of Learning, and Schmidt’s Noticing Hypothesis, provide a comprehensive framework for language teaching. By integrating these models, teachers can create learning experiences that not only build cognitive and linguistic competence but also foster social interaction and real-world language use. Each of Gagné’s events can be enriched by these complementary theories, ensuring that language learners develop both accuracy and communicative fluency in a supportive and cognitively stimulating environment.

Moreover, the integration of these theories emphasizes the importance of addressing learners' diverse needs and abilities. Vygotsky’s focus on the Zone of Proximal Development ensures that instruction is appropriately scaffolded, helping students achieve goals they may not yet reach independently. Luria’s insights into cognitive processes reinforce the value of guiding learners through structured, meaningful activities that engage attention, memory, and problem-solving skills. Together, these approaches highlight the interplay between social interaction and individual cognition in effective language acquisition.

By incorporating Schmidt’s Noticing Hypothesis, teachers can further enhance learners' awareness of linguistic forms and patterns, promoting active engagement with language in context. Encouraging students to notice and reflect on language use both in and beyond the classroom equips them with tools for lifelong learning. Ultimately, the fusion of these theories with Gagné’s instructional framework not only facilitates language acquisition but also empowers learners to apply their skills creatively and confidently in diverse, real-world scenarios.

References

Alber, R. (2011, May 24). 6 Scaffolding Strategies to Use With Your Students. Retrieved November 24, 2024, from Edutopia.Org: https://www.edutopia.org/blog/scaffolding-lessons-six-strategies-rebecca-alber

Bakan, H., Cepanec, V., Dvorski, M., Janeš, J., Milanović, I., Novosel, A., . . . Verveger, I. (2020). The Importance of Error Correction in Foreign Language Learning. Patchwork Student Journal, 7-26. Retrieved October 20, 2024, from https://hrcak.srce.hr/: https://hrcak.srce.hr/file/349678

Buriro, S., & Kakepoto, I. (2023, July). Synthetic and Critical Review of a Second Language Theory: The Noticing Hypothesis of Richard Schmidt. International Journal of English and Education. Retrieved December 3, 2024, from International Journal of English and Education: https://ijee.org/assets/docs/13.17210803.pdf

Ćehić, N. (n.d.). The Benefits of Verbal Feedback. Retrieved November 9, 2024, from https://vibbl.com/: https://vibbl.com/the-benefits-of-verbal-feedback/

Clearwater, L. (n.d.). Understanding the Science Behind Learning Retention. Retrieved November 17, 2024, from Indegene.Com: https://www.indegene.com/what-we-think/reports/understanding-science-behind-learning-retention#reference

Hegwood, V. (2022, November 4). How Teachers Can Recognize & Address Learning Gaps in the Classroom. Retrieved December 11, 2024, from Prodigy.

Jha, A. (2020, October 20). Understanding Your Brain’s Attention System. Retrieved November 29, 2024, from Mindful.Org: https://www.mindful.org/understanding-your-brains-attention-system/

McAllister, K. (2020, September 11). Making and breaking connections in the brain. Retrieved November 11, 2024, from UC Davis Center for Neuroscience: https://neuroscience.ucdavis.edu/news/making-and-breaking-connections-brain

Mccaw, P., & Diamond, A. (2023, November 21). Cognitive Processes in Learning | Definition, Theories & Examples. Retrieved November 21, 2024, from Study.Com: https://study.com/academy/lesson/cognitive-processes-in-learning-types-definition-examples.html#:~:text=The%20cognitive%20process%20involves%20obtaining,memory%2C%20perception%2C%20and%20thought.

McLeod, S. (2024, August 9). Vygotsky’s Theory of Cognitive Development. Retrieved November 9, 2024, from SimplyPsychology.Org: https://www.simplypsychology.org/vygotsky.html

Medical College of Wisconsin: Office of Educational Improvement. (2022, My). Sociocultural Theory of Cognitive Development. Retrieved December 7, 2024, from Medical College of Wisconsin: https://www.mcw.edu/-/media/MCW/Education/Academic-Affairs/OEI/Faculty-Quick-Guides/Sociocultural-Theory-of-Cognitive-Development.pdf

Northern Illinois University Center for Innovative Teaching and Learning. (2020). Gagné’s nine events of instruction. Retrieved December 3, 2024, from Instructional guide for university faculty and teaching assistants: https://www.niu.edu/citl/resources/guides/instructional-guide/gagnes-nine-events-of-instruction.shtml

Schmidt, R. (1995). Attention and Awareness in Foreign Language Learning. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press.

Spina Bifida Hydrocephalus Scotland. (n.d.). Planning, sequencing and monitoring. Retrieved December 16, 2024, from https://www.hydrocephalusscotland.org.uk/: https://www.hydrocephalusscotland.org.uk/content/planning-sequencing-monitoring/

Springer Science+Business Media, LLC. (2012). Explicit and Implicit Learning. doi:ttps://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4419-1428-6_2166

Subbotsky, E. (n.d.). Vygotsky's Distinction Between Lower and Higher Mental Functions and Recent Studies on Infant Cognitive Development. Retrieved December 20, 2024, from Hanover College Psychology Department: https://psych.hanover.edu/vygotsky/subbot.html#:~:text=Indeed%2C%20as%20it%20was%20already,in%20systems%20with%20other%20functions.