skip to main | skip to sidebar
Reflective Online Teaching
My Personal Site for Reflective Teaching
RSS
    Jonathan Acuña Solano, Post Author
    Contact Email: jonacuso@gmail.com

Balancing Guidance and Independence in Effective Teaching Practices

ELT, Guided Practice, Independent Practice, Teaching Practices 0 comments

Moose Refreshing in Lake Mary, Salt Lake City, Utah
Picture taken by Jonathan Acuña in 2022

To give shift learning and put it in the hands of learners, as it is studied at the Arizona State University’s online TESOL certification, language-teaching professionals need to create a solid instructional sequencing of language practice and production activities aligned with the underlying end-product that needs to be achieved according to the one’s lesson plan. This instructional sequence implies guiding students (scaffolding their learning process) towards independent practice.

Here you have some of my reflective journaling notes around the need of balancing guidance and independence when one is with students in the English classroom (Acuña, 2021). 


Balancing Guidance and Independence

in Effective Teaching Practices

Guided practice is a crucial teaching strategy where one finds the teacher orchestrating an activity and guiding students through it carefully and successfully. This method allows learners to engage with the material actively while still having the support of their language instructor. Since the language instructor does not want to be appalled at students’ sense of helplessness in class activities, the teacher's presence ensures that any confusion can be addressed immediately, providing a solid foundation for course content understanding for later use in the lesson. This guided interaction helps build confidence and competence in the new subject matter being studied, making it easier for students to transition to less guided or independent activities to be happening later on in the class continuum.

In less guided (or semi-controlled) activities, pairs or groups of learners collaborate to apply what they've learned through instruction and modeling orchestrated by their teacher or what they might have learned on their own while either working on the school platform / workbooks or working on their own exploration of the language. This collaborative, guided effort allows students to learn from each other while still having the security of their classmates' support. Of course, in case learners feel a shudder pass through them while using English in a more public, controlled speaking environment, the teacher remains available to assist if needed, but the primary responsibility for learning shifts to the students. This type of activity helps develop teamwork and communication skills among language learners, and it reinforces the lesson content through peer interaction and cognitive exploration of course content and its possible applications.

Independent practice takes this a step further by challenging students to think independently and apply their knowledge without immediate teacher intervention. They are like eagles at this stage, pouncing down upon their prey, the language production exercise. During this phase, students must rely on their understanding and problem-solving skills to complete language production tasks. Teachers play an active role by circulating the classroom, ensuring students understand the directions, and answering any questions that arise. This ongoing support helps keep students on task focused on the activity’s goal and prevents them from becoming distracted. Independent practice becomes what is commonly known as language production where students negotiate meaning with peers by trying out what they already know while the teacher monitors their performance for the sake of getting prompt and helpful feedback. Independent practice becomes the cradle of true language acquisition allowing learners to witness, in first person, they can communicate using the newly acquired language lexical or grammatical content.

The forefathers of language teaching -long ago- discovered that independent practice can extend beyond the classroom as homework, providing additional opportunities for students to demonstrate their understanding. Homework serves as a critical tool for teachers to gauge how well students have comprehended the lesson especially when language learners cognitively interact with lexical and grammatical exercises -on their own- on the course platform or course workbook. Activities for independent practice should be a direct extension of previous guided practices carried out during class time, ensuring continuity in student language comprehension, practice, and learning. Teachers should read through instructions with students beforehand to clarify any uncertainties about this type of independent language work, rather than expecting students to decipher instructions on their own, or in the worst-case scenario, getting learners to ask what they had to do then, which actually happens often, when homework is delivered or checked in the classroom.

The teacher's role during independent practice is far from passive; independent practice does not mean break time for the language coach. The idea that teachers relieve them of classroom toil when they create language activities is way too wrong. It is essential for teachers to walk around the classroom, monitoring students' progress and aiding when necessary. This active involvement helps maintain a focused and productive learning environment for the learners. Ensuring that students follow directions and stay on task is crucial for the effectiveness of independent language production practice. This method of active monitoring allows teachers to address any issues promptly and keeps the learning process on track and as an ongoing process. The righteous language instructors will not be beset by a prolonged series of student failure if their participation in independent practice is proactive.

Guided and independent practice activities are complementary approaches in the teaching and in the content assimilation process; they are pawns in one’s path to achieving student language learning success. Guided practice, whether led by the teacher or conducted in small groups, provides a safe environment for students to engage with new lexical and grammatical concepts. It needs to be understood that less guided practice is not a whimsical role of language teaching; it does promote collaboration and peer learning. Independent practice allows students to demonstrate their understanding and apply their knowledge autonomously. By balancing these methods, teachers can create a dynamic and supportive learning environment that fosters both independence and mastery of the subject matter studied in class.

References

Acuña, J. (2021, October 10). What is Independent Practice? Balancing Guidance and Independence in Effective Teaching Practices. San José, San José, Costa Rica.



Comprehension Exercise

After reading this blog post, test your understanding by taking the following comprehension quiz.

  1. Guided practice is primarily characterized by:

●      a) Teacher-led activities.

●      b) Independent student work.

●      c) Peer teaching.

●      d) Homework assignments.

  1. During less guided practice, students:

●      a) Work individually on tasks.

●      b) Collaborate in pairs or groups.

●      c) Listen to a lecture.

●      d) Take a test.

  1. Independent practice helps students by:

●      a) Providing immediate answers.

●      b) Challenging them to apply knowledge independently.

●      c) Teaching new content.

●      d) Allowing them to take a break.

  1. The teacher's role during independent practice includes:

●      a) Sitting at their desk.

●      b) Walking around the class.

●      c) Giving a lecture.

●      d) Grading papers.

  1. Independent practice can extend outside the classroom as:

●      a) Group projects.

●      b) Lab experiments.

●      c) Homework.

●      d) In-class assignments.

  1. To ensure students understand directions during independent practice, teachers should:

●      a) Let students figure it out on their own.

●      b) Read instructions with students.

●      c) Provide written instructions only.

●      d) Give verbal instructions and leave the room.

  1. Guided practice can be conducted by:

●      a) Only the teacher.

●      b) Students independently.

●      c) Teacher or in small groups.

●      d) Substitutes.

  1. Less guided practice primarily involves:

●      a) Teacher lectures.

●      b) Student collaboration.

●      c) Individual tests.

●      d) Homework.

  1. Independent practice provides teachers insight into:

●      a) Students' prior knowledge.

●      b) Students' comprehension of a lesson.

●      c) Students' personal lives.

●      d) Students' handwriting.

  1. A critical aspect of the teacher's role during independent practice is:

●      a) Assigning grades.

●      b) Ensuring students follow directions.

●      c) Preparing future lessons.

●      d) Conducting research.

Answer Key

  1. a) Teacher-led activities.
  2. b) Collaborate in pairs or groups.
  3. b) Challenging them to apply knowledge independently.
  4. b) Walking around the class.
  5. c) Homework.
  6. b) Read instructions with students.
  7. c) Teacher or in small groups.
  8. b) Student collaboration.
  9. b) Students' comprehension of a lesson.
  10. b) Ensuring students follow directions.

Balancing Guidance and Inde... by Jonathan Acuña



Balancing Guidance and Inde... by Jonathan Acuña








Wednesday, June 05, 2024



0 responses to "Balancing Guidance and Independence in Effective Teaching Practices"


Post a Comment

Newer Post Older Post Home
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

    Reflective Online Teaching

    Reflective Online Teaching
    Let's learn together

    Visitors

    Costa Rica

    Costa Rica
    My Home Country

    TESOL Certified Instructor

    TESOL Certified Instructor

    Certified Virtual Instructor

    Certified Virtual Instructor

    PD Talks & NCTE-Costa Rica

    PD Talks & NCTE-Costa Rica

    Copyscape

    Protected by Copyscape

    Labels

    • #EdChat (8)
    • #LTTO (14)
    • A1 Learners (1)
    • ABLA (9)
    • Academic Research (9)
    • ADDIE Model (7)
    • Afro-Caribbean Lore (1)
    • Alexander Luria (5)
    • Anansi (1)
    • Andragogy (5)
    • Andy Curtis (1)
    • Apps for Education (1)
    • Assessment (9)
    • Assessment Practices (3)
    • ASSURE (1)
    • Asynchronous Tools (2)
    • Aural/oral skills (1)
    • autonomous learning (1)
    • Barthesian Analysis (5)
    • Behavior (1)
    • Bettelheim (1)
    • Biblical Text Analysis (1)
    • Big Data (6)
    • Blended Learning (1)
    • BlendIt Course (8)
    • Bloom's Taxonomy (5)
    • BNCs (9)
    • Book Critique (2)
    • Book of Job (1)
    • Bookmarking Sites (1)
    • Case Study (4)
    • CEF (2)
    • Classroom Management (2)
    • Cloud Reader (1)
    • Coaching in Teacher Classroom Observation (2)
    • Code of Ethics (1)
    • Communicating about Uncertainty (1)
    • Community of Practice (8)
    • Competency-Based Learning (9)
    • Content Assimilation (1)
    • Content Design (1)
    • CoP (2)
    • Course Project (2)
    • critical skills (1)
    • Critical Thinking Skills (2)
    • Culture (11)
    • Culture Framework (2)
    • Culture Teaching (8)
    • Curriculum Design (2)
    • Curriculum Development (5)
    • Data Science (7)
    • Data-Driven Teaching (5)
    • DDT (1)
    • Deductive Grammar Instruction (2)
    • Deontology (1)
    • Developmental Feedback (1)
    • Diane Larsen-Freeman (1)
    • Didactics (4)
    • Distance Education (2)
    • E-Portfolios (1)
    • Education and Learning (34)
    • Education Technologies (9)
    • Educational Philosophies (1)
    • EFL/ESL Activities (1)
    • Electracy (1)
    • ELF (1)
    • ELL (16)
    • ELL. ELT (1)
    • ELT (35)
    • ELT Conference (1)
    • English Grammar (3)
    • English Teaching (1)
    • Enkidu (1)
    • Eric Mazur (1)
    • ESP (2)
    • Ethical Judgments (1)
    • Ethics (37)
    • Ethics Analysis (1)
    • Etiological Storytelling (1)
    • Evaluation (1)
    • Executives' School (9)
    • Ezekiel (1)
    • Fairy Tales (2)
    • Feedback (5)
    • Flipped Classroom (1)
    • Flipped Learning (1)
    • Formative Assessment (1)
    • Forums (1)
    • Frankenstein (1)
    • Freudian Analysis (3)
    • From theory to practice (2)
    • Future for Education? (2)
    • Global Competence (1)
    • Global Ethics (7)
    • Grading Ranges (1)
    • Grammar (3)
    • Guest Author (1)
    • Guided Practice (2)
    • H. G. Wells (1)
    • H.P. Lovecraft (3)
    • Haiku (1)
    • HD Brown (1)
    • Higher Education (49)
    • History (2)
    • Homerton College Cambridge Course (2)
    • Hootcourse (1)
    • Human Rights (1)
    • Hybrid and Blended Learning (61)
    • Hybrid In-person Teaching (1)
    • Idioms (1)
    • Iktomi (1)
    • Independent Practice (1)
    • Inductive Grammar Instruction (2)
    • infographic (1)
    • Instructional Design (3)
    • Integration of Technology into Teaching (10)
    • Interventions in ELL (1)
    • Isaac Asimov (1)
    • Jacque Lacan (1)
    • Jacques de Molay (1)
    • James Thurber (1)
    • Japanese Folklore (1)
    • Jeremiah (1)
    • JotForm (1)
    • Jungian Analysis (4)
    • Kahlil Gibran (2)
    • Kathleen M. Bailey (1)
    • Kirkpatrick Model (1)
    • Knight Templars (1)
    • Lacanian Analysis (4)
    • Language Competences (1)
    • Language Learning (13)
    • Language Teaching (6)
    • Laureate Course Module 3 Teaching with Technology (19)
    • Laureate Educator (4)
    • Laureate Educator in the XXI Century (2)
    • Laureate Educator-Week 1 (1)
    • Laureate Educator-Week 2 (1)
    • Laureate Educator-Week 3 (1)
    • Leadership (9)
    • learner autonomy (1)
    • Learning (8)
    • Learning Activities (1)
    • Learning Objectives (2)
    • Learning Preferences (1)
    • Learning Styles (1)
    • Les Demoiselles d’Avignon. Pablo Picasso (1)
    • Lesson Planning (4)
    • Lev Vygotsky (4)
    • Libraries (1)
    • Life is a Dream (1)
    • Life Stories (1)
    • Linguistics (2)
    • Listening (1)
    • Literary Criticism (15)
    • Literature (29)
    • LMS (6)
    • LOTI Profile (5)
    • MakerSpace (1)
    • Marcel Duchamp (4)
    • Mary Shelly (1)
    • Materials Design (1)
    • Meaning of Justice (1)
    • Metacognition (2)
    • Metadata (1)
    • Methodology (2)
    • microcelebrities (1)
    • Mind Maps (2)
    • Mindfulness (12)
    • Mixed-Methods Research (4)
    • Modeling in ELT (1)
    • MOOCs (1)
    • Moodle (5)
    • Moral Lesson (1)
    • Motivation (2)
    • Music and Learning (1)
    • Mythology (1)
    • Needs Assessment (3)
    • Netiquette (1)
    • Network Community (1)
    • Nicatesol (1)
    • Nive Events of Instruction (1)
    • Nonviolent Communication (6)
    • Nouns in English (1)
    • Objective Writing (1)
    • OER (1)
    • Online Community (1)
    • Online Instruction (55)
    • online learning (44)
    • Online Learning Programs (1)
    • Online Persona (9)
    • Online Program Design (1)
    • online teaching (4)
    • Online Teaching Approach (1)
    • Online Teaching Practices (71)
    • Oral Assessment (1)
    • Oral Communication (1)
    • Oral Skills (2)
    • Paper.li (1)
    • PBL (1)
    • Pedagogy (2)
    • Pedro Calderón de la Barca (1)
    • Peer Instruction (1)
    • Penny Ur (2)
    • Personal Learning Networks (2)
    • Philosophy (1)
    • Phonemics (4)
    • Phonetics (4)
    • Phonotactics (3)
    • Pilot Programs (1)
    • PLEs and PLNs for Lifelong Learning Competencies Week 1 (1)
    • Poetry (1)
    • Popol Vuh (1)
    • Produsage (1)
    • Produser (1)
    • Professional Competencies (1)
    • Professional Growth (1)
    • Projec-Based Learning (1)
    • Pronunciation (7)
    • Psychology (1)
    • Public Speaking (1)
    • Qualitative Research (4)
    • Quantitative Research (4)
    • Reading (1)
    • Reading and Vocabulary (2)
    • Recruitment (1)
    • Recycling in Education (1)
    • Reflective Journaling (4)
    • Reflective Teaching (55)
    • Research (9)
    • Richard Schmidt (2)
    • Risk Communication (1)
    • Robert Gagné (2)
    • Roland Barthes (2)
    • Rubrics (3)
    • Schema (1)
    • Scoop.it! (1)
    • Second Language Acquisition (4)
    • Secret Societies of the Middle Ages (1)
    • Semiotics (1)
    • Sentence Patterns (1)
    • Short Films (1)
    • Short Stories (4)
    • Sioux Legends (3)
    • Sketchpads (1)
    • SLA (3)
    • Social Media (29)
    • Social Networking in Education (3)
    • Speaking (1)
    • Speaking Scenarios (1)
    • Stephen Krashen (1)
    • Sticky Curriculum (1)
    • Storytelling (1)
    • Strategies for online teaching (1)
    • Student Assessment (1)
    • Student Engagement (1)
    • Student Interest (3)
    • Student Motivation (1)
    • Student Tips (2)
    • Sumerian (1)
    • Summative Assessment (1)
    • Syntax (2)
    • Task-Based Instruction (1)
    • Task-Based Language Teaching (1)
    • TBI (1)
    • TBLT (1)
    • Teacher Development (23)
    • Teacher Feedback (2)
    • Teacher Mentoring (2)
    • Teacher Observation (1)
    • Teacher Training (2)
    • Teaching (47)
    • Teaching Adolescents (1)
    • Teaching ePortfolio (1)
    • Teaching Grammar (2)
    • Teaching Online (9)
    • Teaching Philosophy (4)
    • Teaching Portfolio (1)
    • Teaching Practices (49)
    • Teaching Practicum (22)
    • Teaching Presence (2)
    • Teaching Styles (8)
    • Teaching Tips (9)
    • Teaching With Technology (4)
    • Teaching With Technology-Week 1 (1)
    • Teaching With Technology-Week 2 (1)
    • Teaching With Technology-Week 3 (2)
    • Teaching With Technology-Week 4 (4)
    • Teaching With Technology-Week 5 (3)
    • Teaching With Technology-Week 6 (2)
    • Teaching With Technology-Week 7 (3)
    • Teaching With Technology-Week 8 (2)
    • Teaching With Technology-Week 9 (1)
    • Tech Tip (5)
    • Technological Assessment (2)
    • Technology Use Tips (1)
    • Templars (1)
    • The Assassins (1)
    • The Book of Proverbs (1)
    • The Butterfly Circus (1)
    • The Cats of Ulthar (1)
    • The Data Scientist (5)
    • The Epic of Gilgamish (1)
    • The Loincloth (1)
    • The New Normal (1)
    • The Noticing Hypothesis (2)
    • The Outsider (1)
    • The Prophet (2)
    • The Time Machine (1)
    • Thomas Keightley (2)
    • Tolkien (1)
    • Trickster (1)
    • UCC (1)
    • Universidad Mariano Gálvez (2)
    • Utilitarianism (1)
    • Videoconferencing Platforms (1)
    • Virtual Classroom Features (1)
    • Virtual Learning Environments (8)
    • Virtual Teaching (5)
    • Virtualized Teaching (1)
    • Visual Literacy (1)
    • VLE (47)
    • VLEs (38)
    • Vocabulary learning (10)
    • WAS (14)
    • Web 2.0 (4)
    • Web search engine options (1)
    • Web Tools (6)
    • WebQuests (1)
    • Wilbert Salgado (4)
    • William Elliot Griffis (1)
    • Working Adult Student (5)
    • writing (2)
    • Writing Skills (1)
    • Zecharia Sitchin (1)
    • ZPD (1)

    Blog Archive

    • ►  2025 (19)
      • ►  June (2)
      • ►  May (3)
      • ►  April (4)
      • ►  March (6)
      • ►  February (2)
      • ►  January (2)
    • ▼  2024 (28)
      • ►  December (3)
      • ►  November (2)
      • ►  October (4)
      • ►  September (4)
      • ►  August (5)
      • ►  July (3)
      • ▼  June (2)
        • Enhancing Language Learning Through Effective Asse...
        • Balancing Guidance and Independence in Effective T...
      • ►  May (2)
      • ►  April (3)
    • ►  2023 (6)
      • ►  September (1)
      • ►  August (5)
    • ►  2022 (1)
      • ►  July (1)
    • ►  2020 (54)
      • ►  November (4)
      • ►  October (7)
      • ►  September (11)
      • ►  August (15)
      • ►  July (10)
      • ►  April (2)
      • ►  March (5)
    • ►  2019 (13)
      • ►  August (5)
      • ►  July (8)
    • ►  2018 (11)
      • ►  June (2)
      • ►  May (7)
      • ►  April (2)
    • ►  2017 (6)
      • ►  May (2)
      • ►  April (2)
      • ►  January (2)
    • ►  2016 (101)
      • ►  November (4)
      • ►  October (7)
      • ►  September (10)
      • ►  August (4)
      • ►  May (22)
      • ►  April (17)
      • ►  March (21)
      • ►  February (14)
      • ►  January (2)
    • ►  2015 (53)
      • ►  November (5)
      • ►  October (13)
      • ►  August (4)
      • ►  July (8)
      • ►  June (5)
      • ►  May (14)
      • ►  April (4)
    • ►  2014 (40)
      • ►  October (5)
      • ►  September (11)
      • ►  August (4)
      • ►  June (3)
      • ►  May (8)
      • ►  April (5)
      • ►  February (1)
      • ►  January (3)
    • ►  2013 (46)
      • ►  December (1)
      • ►  November (1)
      • ►  October (3)
      • ►  September (5)
      • ►  August (6)
      • ►  July (7)
      • ►  June (6)
      • ►  May (7)
      • ►  April (1)
      • ►  March (4)
      • ►  February (3)
      • ►  January (2)
    • ►  2012 (17)
      • ►  December (3)
      • ►  November (4)
      • ►  October (4)
      • ►  September (6)
    • ►  2011 (5)
      • ►  September (2)
      • ►  August (2)
      • ►  January (1)
    • ►  2010 (46)
      • ►  December (9)
      • ►  November (14)
      • ►  October (3)
      • ►  March (4)
      • ►  February (8)
      • ►  January (8)

Copyright © All Rights Reserved. Reflective Online Teaching | Converted into Blogger Templates by Theme Craft